Discrete Mathematics with Applications 4th Edition

Published by Cengage Learning
ISBN 10: 0-49539-132-8
ISBN 13: 978-0-49539-132-6

Chapter 6 - Set Theory - Exercise Set 6.4 - Page 382: 25

Answer

No, there is no such algorithm. The printing problem is undecidable because it would allow us to solve the Halting Problem, which is known to be unsolvable.

Work Step by Step

### ❓ Problem: The **Printing Problem** > Is there an algorithm that, for a **fixed output \( a \)**, can decide for **any program \( X \)** and **any input data \( D \)** whether \( X \), when run on \( D \), **prints \( a \)**? --- ### βœ… Short Answer: \[ \boxed{\text{No, such an algorithm cannot exist.}} \] --- ### 🧠 Explanation: This problem is **undecidable** β€” it’s closely related to the **Halting Problem**, and we can prove it by **reduction**. --- ### πŸ” Intuition Behind the Undecidability: If such a printing-decider existed, you could use it to **solve the Halting Problem**, which is known to be undecidable. **How?** You could write a program \( X \) that prints \( a \) **if and only if** it halts on input \( D \). Then ask the printing-decider whether \( X \) prints \( a \). - If it says **yes**, then \( X \) halts on \( D \). - If it says **no**, then \( X \) does not halt on \( D \). This would **solve the Halting Problem**, which we know is impossible. --- ### βœ… Therefore: The printing problem is **undecidable**: There is **no algorithm** that can, in general, determine whether an arbitrary program \( X \), given arbitrary input \( D \), will print a fixed output \( a \).
Update this answer!

You can help us out by revising, improving and updating this answer.

Update this answer

After you claim an answer you’ll have 24 hours to send in a draft. An editor will review the submission and either publish your submission or provide feedback.