Box office
Magnolia initially opened in a limited release on December 17, 1999, in seven theaters grossing $193,604. The film was given a wide release on January 7, 2000, in 1,034 theaters grossing $5.7 million on its opening weekend. It eventually grossed $22.5 million in the United States and Canada, and $26.0 million in other territories, for a worldwide total of $48.5 million, against a budget of $37 million.[27]
Critical response
There is no film ... EVER ... that has made me think and made me feel and made me question like Magnolia. It made me laugh and cry and squirm and giggle with nervous laughter. Yet, I can't deny that five years later my life is changed because I've seen Magnolia. I sit here at my computer getting goosebumps at the tenderness of Philip Seymour Hoffman.
—Film critic Richard Propes on the impact of Magnolia.[28]
On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 82% of 216 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 7.6/10. The website's consensus reads: "An eruption of feeling that's as overwhelming as it is overwrought, Paul Thomas Anderson's Magnolia reaches a fevered crescendo and sustains it thanks to its fearlessly committed ensemble."[29] Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned the film a score of 78 out of 100, based on 34 critics, indicating "generally favorable" reviews.[30] Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "C-" on an A+ to F scale.[31]
USA Today gave the film three and a half stars out of four and called it "the most imperfect of the year's best movies".[32] Roger Ebert from the Chicago Sun-Times awarded the film four stars out of four, praising it in both of his reviews from 2000 and 2008, and as his second favorite film of 1999, behind Being John Malkovich. He said in the first review, "Magnolia is the kind of film I instinctively respond to. Leave logic at the door. Do not expect subdued taste and restraint, but instead a kind of operatic ecstasy".[33] After rewatching it in 2008, he added the film to his 'Great Movies' list.[34] Entertainment Weekly gave the film a "B+" rating, praising Cruise's performance: "It's with Cruise as Frank T.J. Mackey, a slick televangelist of penis power, that the filmmaker scores his biggest success, as the actor exorcises the uptight fastidiousness of Eyes Wide Shut ... Like John Travolta in Pulp Fiction, this cautiously packaged movie star is liberated by risky business".[35] The Independent said that the film was "limitless. And yet some things do feel incomplete, brushed-upon, tangential. Magnolia does not have the last word on anything. But is superb".[36] Kenneth Turan, in his review for the Los Angeles Times, praised Tom Cruise's performance: "Mackey gives Cruise the chance to cut loose by doing amusing riffs on his charismatic superstar image. It's great fun, expertly written and performed, and all the more enjoyable because the self-parody element is unexpected".[37] In his review for The New York Observer, Andrew Sarris wrote, "In the case of Magnolia, I think Mr. Anderson has taken us to the water's edge without plunging in. I admire his ambition and his very eloquent camera movements, but if I may garble something Lenin once said one last time, 'You can't make an omelet without breaking some eggs'."[38]
In her review for The New York Times, Janet Maslin wrote, "But when that group sing-along arrives, Magnolia begins to self-destruct spectacularly. It's astonishing to see a film begin this brilliantly only to torpedo itself in its final hour," but went on to say that the film "was saved from its worst, most reductive ideas by the intimacy of the performances and the deeply felt distress signals given off by the cast".[39] Philip French, in his review for The Observer, wrote, "But is the joyless universe he (Anderson) presents any more convincing than the Pollyanna optimism of traditional sitcoms? These lives are somehow too stunted and pathetic to achieve the level of tragedy".[40] The Time critic Richard Schickel wrote: "The result is a hard-striving, convoluted movie, which never quite becomes the smoothly reciprocating engine Anderson (who did Boogie Nights) would like it to be."[41]
In an interview, Ingmar Bergman mentioned Magnolia as an example of the "strength of American cinema".[42] Roger Ebert included the work in his "Great Movies" list in November 2008, saying, "As an act of filmmaking, it draws us in and doesn't let go."[43] Total Film magazine placed it at number 4 in their list of 50 Best Movies in Total Film's lifetime.[44] In 2008, it was named the 89th greatest movie of all time by Empire magazine in its issue of The 500 Greatest Movies of All Time.[45] It received eight votes – five from critics and three from directors – in the British Film Institute's 2012 Sight & Sound polls.[46]
Following the film's release, Anderson said: "I really feel ... That Magnolia is, for better or worse, the best movie I'll ever make."[47] Later he came to consider it overlong;[48] when asked in interview what he would tell himself to do if he could go back to when he shot the film, his response was "Chill The Fuck Out and Cut Twenty Minutes."[49]
Accolades
Award | Category | Nominee(s) | Result | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
Academy Awards | Best Supporting Actor | Tom Cruise | Nominated | [50] |
Best Screenplay – Written Directly for the Screen | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Original Song | "Save Me" Music and Lyrics by Aimee Mann | Nominated | ||
Berlin International Film Festival | Golden Bear | Paul Thomas Anderson | Won | [51] [52] |
Reader Jury of the "Berliner Morgenpost" | Won | |||
Blockbuster Entertainment Awards | Favorite Supporting Actor – Drama | Tom Cruise | Won | |
Favorite Supporting Actress – Drama | Julianne Moore | Nominated | ||
Bodil Awards | Best American Film | Nominated | [53] | |
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards | Best Film | Nominated | [54] | |
Best Director | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Screenplay | Nominated | |||
Best Supporting Actor | Tom Cruise | Won | ||
Chlotrudis Awards | Best Movie | Nominated | [55] | |
Best Director | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Supporting Actor | Philip Seymour Hoffman (also for The Talented Mr. Ripley) | Won | ||
Best Cinematography | Robert Elswit | Nominated | ||
Critics' Choice Awards | Best Picture | Nominated | [56] | |
Dallas–Fort Worth Film Critics Association Awards | Best Picture | Nominated | ||
Empire Awards | Best Film | Nominated | ||
Best Director | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Florida Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Film | Won | [57] | |
Best Ensemble | Won | |||
Golden Globe Awards | Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture | Tom Cruise | Won | [58] [59] |
Best Original Song – Motion Picture | "Save Me" Music and Lyrics by Aimee Mann | Nominated | ||
Grammy Awards | Best Compilation Soundtrack Album for a Motion Picture, Television or Other Visual Media | Magnolia: Music from the Motion Picture – Aimee Mann | Nominated | [60] |
Best Score Soundtrack Album for a Motion Picture, Television or Other Visual Media | Magnolia – Jon Brion | Nominated | ||
Best Song Written for a Motion Picture, Television or Other Visual Media | "Save Me" – Aimee Mann | Nominated | ||
Grand Prix Cinema Brazil | Best Foreign Language Film | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | |
Guldbagge Awards | Best Foreign Film | Won | ||
Las Vegas Film Critics Society Awards | Best Picture | Nominated | [61] | |
Best Original Song | "Save Me" Music and Lyrics by Aimee Mann | Nominated | ||
Best DVD | Nominated | |||
London Film Critics Circle Awards | Screenwriter of the Year | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | |
MTV Video Music Awards | Best Video from a Film | Aimee Mann – "Save Me" | Nominated | |
Nastro d'Argento | Best Foreign Director | Paul Thomas Anderson | Won | |
Best Male Dubbing | Roberto Chevalier (for dubbing Tom Cruise) | Nominated | ||
National Board of Review Awards | Top Ten Films | 3rd Place | [62] [8] | |
Best Supporting Actor | Philip Seymour Hoffman (also for The Talented Mr. Ripley) | Won | ||
Best Supporting Actress | Julianne Moore (also for A Map of the World, Cookie's Fortune, and An Ideal Husband) | Won | ||
Best Acting by an Ensemble | Won | |||
National Society of Film Critics Awards | Best Supporting Actor | Philip Seymour Hoffman (also for The Talented Mr. Ripley) | 2nd Place | [63] |
Best Supporting Actress | Julianne Moore (also for A Map of the World and An Ideal Husband) | 2nd Place | ||
Online Film & Television Association Awards | Best Picture | JoAnne Sellar and Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | [64] |
Best Director | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Supporting Actor | Tom Cruise | Won | ||
Best Supporting Actress | Julianne Moore | Won | ||
Best Youth Performance | Jeremy Blackman | Nominated | ||
Best Original Screenplay | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Original Song | "Save Me" Music and Lyrics by Aimee Mann | Nominated | ||
Best Adapted Song | "One" Music and Lyrics by Harry Nilsson | Won | ||
Best Casting | Cassandra Kulukundis | Nominated | ||
Best Ensemble | Won | |||
Best Cinematic Moment | "Frogs" | Nominated | ||
Online Film Critics Society Awards (1999) | Top 10 Films | 6th Place | [65] | |
Best Supporting Actress | Julianne Moore | Nominated | ||
Best Screenplay | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Ensemble | Nominated | |||
Online Film Critics Society Awards (2000) | Best DVD | Nominated | [66] | |
Robert Awards | Best American Film | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | |
San Sebastián International Film Festival | Film of the Year | Won | ||
Satellite Awards | Best Motion Picture – Drama | Nominated | [67] | |
Best Director | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Supporting Actor in a Motion Picture – Drama | Tom Cruise | Nominated | ||
Best Screenplay – Original | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | ||
Best Original Song | "Save Me" Music and Lyrics by Aimee Mann | Nominated | ||
Outstanding Motion Picture Ensemble | Won | |||
Screen Actors Guild Awards | Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture | Jeremy Blackman, Tom Cruise, Melinda Dillon, April Grace, Luis Guzmán, Philip Baker Hall, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Ricky Jay, William H. Macy, Alfred Molina, Julianne Moore, John C. Reilly, Jason Robards, and Melora Walters | Nominated | [68] |
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Supporting Role | Tom Cruise | Nominated | ||
Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Supporting Role | Julianne Moore | Nominated | ||
Stinkers Bad Movie Awards | Worst On-Screen Hairstyle (Male) | Tom Cruise | Nominated | [69] |
Most Intrusive Musical Score | Nominated | |||
Toronto Film Critics Association Awards | Best Film | Won | [70] [71] | |
Best Director | Paul Thomas Anderson | Won | ||
Best Screenplay | Won[a] | |||
Turkish Film Critics Association Awards | Best Foreign Film | 7th Place | ||
Village Voice Film Poll | Best Film | 8th Place | [72] | |
Writers Guild of America Awards | Best Screenplay – Written Directly for the Screen | Paul Thomas Anderson | Nominated | [73] |
Young Artist Awards | Best Performance in a Feature Film – Leading Young Actor | Jeremy Blackman | Nominated | [74] |
- In 2004, the American Film Institute nominated the song "Save Me" from this film for AFI's 100 Years ... 100 Songs.[75]