Atlantia received reviews from the School Library Journal,[2] Justine Magazine, Salt Lake City Weekly,[3] and Shelf Awareness.[4]
Atlantia was also reviewed by multiple noted authors, including Shannon Hale, who wrote, "“Utterly captivating. A heroine unlike any I’d met before, a setting I’d never glimpsed, a story I’d never imagined. Atlantia is fresh, wild, and engrossing. I love Ally Condie.”