The irony of the threats
Pip receives several threatening notes advising her to halt her investigation, but she persists, and her dog is discovered dead. The irony in this situation is that Pip received several threatening notes warning her to discontinue her investigation, but she persisted despite the dangers. Unfortunately, her tenacity cost her dearly when her beloved dog was discovered dead. Despite the threats and the death of her dog, Pip persisted and eventually discovered the truth about Andie and Sal's disappearance.
The irony of Mr. Wad’s actions
It's ironic that Mr. Ward, the person she trusted, was ultimately responsible for Andie's disappearance. He was a well-known history teacher in the community who served as a mentor to both Andie and Pip. Despite this, he was ultimately responsible for Andie's disappearance, and his actions had irreversible consequences for both Andie's and Sal's lives.
Irony of judging
The irony in Pip's capstone presentation is that she is essentially condemning the people of Fairview for jumping to conclusions in the case of Sal's guilt, even though she was initially convinced of his guilt. She was quick to pass judgment and jump to conclusions without any evidence to back up her claims. Furthermore, the same people who harshly judged Sal were the same people on whom Pip had to rely for assistance in her investigation. Even though they had already found Sal guilty, they were the ones who provided her with the information she needed to uncover the truth. This irony emphasizes the danger of jumping to conclusions and shows the importance of understanding all angles of a situation before concluding.
The irony of the kidnapping
It is ironic that Mr. Ward held a girl captive in his attic for five years, mistaking her for Andie when she was not. He was attempting to shield himself from the truth of his involvement in Andie's disappearance and protect his reputation, but he ended up in a situation far worse than the one he was attempting to avoid.
The irony of Andie’s death
It's ironic that Becca, Andie's own sister, was the one who murdered her and disposed of her body. It's a heartbreaking reminder of how complicated human relationships can be. Becca had the opportunity, access, and motive to carry out her plan, and she was able to do so for five years until Pip's investigation revealed the truth. Becca's actions serve as a stark reminder of how far people will go to conceal the truth, even if it involves a loved one.
