O Pioneers

How old is Alexandra in Part I?

In Part II, she is 40 and Carl is 35. It is confirmed in this part that Carl is about 5 yrs. younger than Alexandra. In Part II, 16 yrs have passed since her father's death. That would suggest she is 24 yrs. old in Part I.

However, in Chapter 1 it says that Carl is 15 yrs. old. That would make Alexandra 20 yrs old in Part I.

How is this discrepancy explained? Am I missing something? Did 4 yrs. pass betwen Chapter 1 and Chapter 3? It seems like her father was on his deathbed at the end of Chapter 2, so that doesn't really make sense to me.

Asked by
Last updated by Aslan
Answers 1
Add Yours

I don't think discrepancy is explained. As you alluded to, the author does not deal with ages of characters in any detail.