The Church's treatment of Aunt Julia in The Dead

Why does Aunt Kate beliece that the Church's treament of Aunt Julia is unjust?

Asked by
Last updated by Aslan
Answers 1
Add Yours

There is some criticism of the Church and sexism. Aunt Kate starts talking about how Julia's voice was wasted in the Church choir. Aunt Julia worked hard hours, rising early, to sing in the Church choir. Her work came to naught when Pope Pius X issued an order banning women from church choirs. Aunt Kate goes from saying that she doesn't question the pope, who must be right (since Aunt Kate is only a stupid old woman) to saying that there's such a thing as simple gratitude and decency (which, we can infer, the pope's order set aside).