On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a 73% approval rating, based on 177 reviews, with the average rating of 6.87/10. The site's consensus reads: "A fun, whimsical tale about an office drone trying to save his life from his narrator, Stranger Than Fiction features a subdued performance from Will Ferrell that contributes mightily to its quirky, mind-bending effect."[10] On Metacritic, the film holds a score of 67 out of 100, based on 35 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews".[11] Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film a grade of "B+" on a scale of A+ to F.[12]
Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times gave the film 3.5 stars out of 4, stating that the film was thought-provoking and moral, and that "such an uncommonly intelligent film does not often get made...which requires us to enter the lives of these specific quiet, sweet, worthy people". He also praised Ferrell's performance, saying, "Will Ferrell stars, in another role showing that like Steve Martin and Robin Williams he has dramatic gifts to equal his comedic talent."[13]
Rolling Stone rated the film 3 stars out of 4, stating that, although the premise of Ferrell's life being narrated is a set-up for farce, the film is "less self-reflexively clever and more intimate".[14]
Todd McCarthy in Variety reviewed the film positively, praising its invention, and Ferrell's performance as nuanced; first playing a tight focused caricature of the company man, then exercising more humanity and wit without being "goofy".[8]
Accolades
Award | Category | Nominee(s) | Result | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
Alliance of Women Film Journalists | Best Comedy by or About Women | Marc Forster | Nominated | [15] [16] |
Best Actress in a Comedic Performance | Emma Thompson | Nominated | ||
Critics' Choice Awards | Best Supporting Actress | Nominated | [17] | |
Best Writer | Zach Helm | Nominated | ||
Golden Globe Awards | Best Actor in a Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy | Will Ferrell | Nominated | [18] |
Hollywood Film Awards | Casting Director of the Year | Francine Maisler (Also for Babel and Miami Vice) | Won | [19] |
London Film Critics Circle Awards | British Supporting Actress of the Year | Emma Thompson | Nominated | [20] |
National Board of Review Awards | Best Original Screenplay | Zach Helm | Won | [21] |
PEN America Literary Awards | Best Screenplay | Won | ||
Satellite Awards | Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy | Nominated | [22] | |
Best Actor in a Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy | Will Ferrell | Nominated | ||
Saturn Awards | Best Fantasy Film | Nominated | [23] | |
Best Actor | Will Ferrell | Nominated | ||
Best Actress | Maggie Gyllenhaal | Nominated | ||
Best Supporting Actress | Emma Thompson | Nominated | ||
Best Writing | Zach Helm | Nominated | ||
Utah Film Critics Association Awards | Best Supporting Actress | Maggie Gyllenhaal | Nominated | [24] |
Writers Guild of America Awards | Best Original Screenplay | Zach Helm | Nominated | [25] |