Atlantia received reviews from the School Library Journal, Justine Magazine, Salt Lake City Weekly, and Shelf Awareness.
Atlantia was also reviewed by multiple noted authors, including Shannon Hale, who wrote, "“Utterly captivating. A heroine unlike any I’d met before, a setting I’d never glimpsed, a story I’d never imagined. Atlantia is fresh, wild, and engrossing. I love Ally Condie.”