Trifles

Are the women justified in their choice to hide the evidence? Choose a side, and be sure to cite textual evidence for support

Write a paragraph arguing the following point: Are the women justified in their choice to hide the evidence? Choose a side, and be sure to cite textual evidence for support

Asked by
Last updated by Aslan
Answers 1
Add Yours

On the one hand, the women have chosen to protect Minnie Wright because they see themselves in her and do not want to be hypocritical and condemn her. Minnie has been desperately lonely and unhappy for many years, going through emotional and possibly physical abuse from her husband, and the killing of the only living thing that cares for her may have justified retribution in kind. On the other hand, one could contend that Mrs. Wright has still committed murder, and neither the death of an animal nor years of marital troubles excuses homicide. By aiding and abetting her, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters are effectively accomplices who have condoned murder.