ok. Holden doesnt really like people but he does like people. he only hates them if they wont go away, but if they havnt been seen by holden in a while then he beggins to miss them. he also says that many of the people are phonies. what is a phony? people who run away.. and blablabla. what ever. if that is said isnt holden himself a phony?
The Catcher in the Rye Forum
Join the discussion about The Catcher in the Rye by creating a new topic or replying to an existing topic. You may also view GradeSaver's College Discussion Forums or other Novel Discussion Forums.
phonies...
This is probably really late, but in case anyone else had the same problem...
That's a really good point, and I think you're right, to a certain extent, Holden is just as phony as everyone around him, even if only due to his constantly judging others. However, through most of the book, his definition of phony isn't someone who is fake, it's someone who conforms. That is why, as far as Holden is concerned, he is (with maybe two or so exceptions in the story) the only real person left. His attempts to stand out are seen several times throughout the story. An example of this is his hunting hat and how he several times at the beginning points out how he wears it backwards.
That's a really good point, and I think you're right, to a certain extent, Holden is just as phony as everyone around him, even if only due to his constantly judging others. However, through most of the book, his definition of phony isn't someone who is fake, it's someone who conforms. That is why, as far as Holden is concerned, he is (with maybe two or so exceptions in the story) the only real person left. His attempts to stand out are seen several times throughout the story. An example of this is his hunting hat and how he several times at the beginning points out how he wears it backwards.
You must login to post to this topic.
Existing Users
New Users
Related Content for The Catcher in the Rye
