The Book Thief

why might death have agreed wit hans hubermann that his act of ccompassion was "stupid"?

part seven discussion questions

Asked by
Last updated by Aslan
Answers 1
Add Yours

Hans appears to have given the bread to the older Jew almost instinctively, without thought. Liesel is deeply impressed by Hans' brave and selfless humanity, yet Hans regrets his action. Hans has brought increased scrutiny towards his family, and Max can no longer safely remain with the Hubermanns. In offering a piece of bread to a frail Jew who is virtually certain to die, Hans endangers the life of the healthier, younger, and freer Max. Moreover, the older Jew, who does not even take the bread, is harshly punished. By this line of reasoning, Hans made an illogical and foolish decision that harmed many people without helping anyone.

Source(s)

http://www.gradesaver.com/the-book-thief/study-guide/section8/