Physics for Scientists and Engineers: A Strategic Approach with Modern Physics (3rd Edition)

Published by Pearson
ISBN 10: 0321740904
ISBN 13: 978-0-32174-090-8

Chapter 18 - The Micro/Macro Connection - Conceptual Questions - Page 522: 8

Answer

a) Greater than. b) Less than.

Work Step by Step

a) Since the two gases are in contact for a long time, they have the same temperature. Now we need to figure out whether their molecules have the same RMS speed or not. We know that the RMS speed is given by $$v_{\rm rms} =\sqrt{\dfrac{3k_BT}{m}}$$ Hence, $$\dfrac{v_{\rm rms,He} }{v_{\rm rms,Ar} }=\dfrac{\sqrt{\dfrac{3k_BT}{m_{\rm He}}}}{\sqrt{\dfrac{3k_BT}{m_{\rm Ar}}}}$$ $$\dfrac{v_{\rm rms,He} }{v_{\rm rms,Ar} }=\sqrt{\dfrac{m_{\rm Ar}}{m_{\rm He}}}\tag 1$$ Now we need to find the mass of helium and argon. $$n_{He}=\dfrac{m_{\rm He}}{M_{\rm He}}$$ Hence, $$m_{\rm He}=n_{He}M_{\rm He}=(0.1)(4)=0.4\;\rm g$$ By the same approach, $$m_{\rm Ar}=n_{Ar}M_{\rm Ar}=(0.2)(39.9)=7.98\;\rm g$$ Plugging into (1); $$\dfrac{v_{\rm rms,He} }{v_{\rm rms,Ar} }=\sqrt{\dfrac{7.98 }{0.4 }}=\bf 4.5 $$ Therefore, $$v_{\rm rms,He} =4.5v_{\rm rms,Ar} $$ And hence, $$\boxed{v_{\rm rms,He}\gt v_{\rm rms,Ar} }$$ --- b) The thermal energy for monatomic gases, like helium and argon, is given by $$E_{th}=\dfrac{3}{2}nRT$$ So, $$\dfrac{(E_{th})_{He}}{(E_{th})_{Ar}}=\dfrac{\frac{3}{2}n_{He}RT}{\frac{3}{2}n_{Ar}RT}$$ We know that both gases are at the same temperature. So, $$\dfrac{(E_{th})_{He}}{(E_{th})_{Ar}}=\dfrac{ n_{He} }{n_{Ar} }=\dfrac{0.1}{0.2}=\frac{1}{2}$$ Therefore, $${(E_{th})_{Ar}}=2{(E_{th})_{He}}$$ And hence, $$\boxed{{(E_{th})_{Ar}}\gt {(E_{th})_{He}}}$$
Update this answer!

You can help us out by revising, improving and updating this answer.

Update this answer

After you claim an answer you’ll have 24 hours to send in a draft. An editor will review the submission and either publish your submission or provide feedback.