GradeSaver (TM) Classicnotes Macbeth: Study Guide
Home : Macbeth : Forum : Forum Topic

Macbeth Forum

Join the discussion about Macbeth by creating a new topic or replying to an existing topic. You may also view GradeSaver's College Discussion Forums or other Novel Discussion Forums.

Lady Macbeth vs Macbeth

Who is more responsible for Duncans murder. Lady Macbeth or Macbeth? and why?
Posted by paul p #40052 at Apr 25, 2007 9:37 PM || Report this post || Reply

lady macbeth was great
Posted by daniel g #46996 at Nov 05, 2007 6:50 AM || Report this post || Reply

lady macbeth! she provoked her husband to do it it was her that first thought of murder realisticly ie when macbeth thought of it he tries to hide it and not think about it "let not light see my deep and dark desires" and lady macbeth questioned his manhood and bullied him into doing it...!! i think macbeth lost it afterwards but defo lady macbeth is responsible for duncans death
Posted by sarah n #48555 at Nov 14, 2007 2:48 PM || Report this post || Reply

Ok but why did she eventually go crazy and turn herself into an evil spirit?
Posted by chelsey h #89051 at Apr 16, 2009 5:59 PM || Report this post || Reply

Yeah.
Great, nah far from it she is manipulative and calculating with a double spice of Evil!
Posted by henry m #98491 at Jul 07, 2009 9:12 AM || Report this post || Reply

idk my bff jell
Posted by robert o #99269 at Jul 20, 2009 6:23 PM || Report this post || Reply

This is an interesting question. I would argue that Macbeth is certainly more to blame for the murder, but the paradoxical idea that Lady Macbeth has the upper-hand in the relationship would lead us to believe that Lady Macbeth is in fact more responsible for the regicide. However, if you look to the end result, Macbeth emerges as the ruthless killer, unscarred by the death of his wife, while she on the other hand becomes so full of grief that she takes her own life. This proves that Macbeth had always been murderous, showing no remorse, while Lady Macbeth simply hid her true emotions to bring rise to the theme of appearance vs reality. So I would definitely say Macbeth is more responsible.
Posted by brian g #111393 at Nov 04, 2009 5:07 PM || Report this post || Reply

 

You must login to post to this topic.

Existing Users

New Users

Must contain six characters and at least one digit.

Related Content for Macbeth