King Lear's Three Deaths: Triumph, Nihilism, and Revision
If Shakespeare penned two King Lears, he created three King Lears. There is the Quarto's hero, the Folio's hero, and the hero who exists somewhere in the interplay. The last of these is not the same Lear who emerges variously in various conflated editions. That Lear is an editor's creation. The Lear I refer to contradicts himself at one and the same moment, could never be seen on any stage, and dies two very different deaths.
In an essay on Hamlet's textual problems, Stanley Urkowitz wrote that comparing Q1 to Q2 is "rather like [perusing] a museum or a gallery showing the variant states of the great Rembrandt etchings... Each can stand alone, but when viewed side by side they show how the work grew and altered, and we can better appreciate the particular virtues of each trial." At this hypothetical Rembrandt exhibit a visitor to the museum might also concern himself with the question of what the differences between the etchings mean in themselves. A mole on an attractive woman's nose that grows bigger from etching to etching suggests something about Rembrandt's conception of beauty. The revisions might say as much about Rembrandt's art as his discreet productions.
There are many important...
Join Now to View Premium Content
GradeSaver provides access to 739 study guide PDFs and quizzes, 4398 literature essays, 1440 sample college application essays, 178 lesson plans, and ad-free surfing in this premium content, “Members Only” section of the site! Membership includes a 10% discount on all editing orders.
Already a member? Log in