Cry, the Beloved Country (Oprah's Book Club)
Home : Cry, the Beloved Country : Forum : Forum Topic

Cry, the Beloved Country Forum

Join the discussion about Cry, the Beloved Country by creating a new topic or replying to an existing topic. You may also view GradeSaver's College Discussion Forums or other Novel Discussion Forums.

similarities and differences between jarvis and kumalo

help me please
Posted by j b #80453 at Feb 17, 2009 7:32 AM || Report this post || Reply

Similarities: Both suffer during the story. I dont know anything else
Differences: Kumalo never distinguished between white and black, while Jarvis was selfish and did not respect black people
Posted by r e #80457 at Feb 17, 2009 7:37 AM || Report this post || Reply

Both Kumalo and Mr. Jarvis are searching for their sons. One physically(Kumalo), and one unknowingly(Mr. Jarvis). Similarities include as well the revelations both experience prior to learning alraming news of their sons. Mr. Jarvis sees the injustice of social inequality in South Africa. While Kumalo realizes the consequences of losing tribal customs. And how Christianity can lead a population to sleep, or support oppresive ideas.
Posted by marleene c #83163 at Mar 06, 2009 10:43 PM || Report this post || Reply

Both Kumalo and Jarvis are quiet and thoughtful. Each of them grieves over the loss of a son, yet each of them respond so beautifully- they both open their hearts. Both acted in compassionate ways. Both were humble men. Both we're beginning again as fathers with their grandsons. Both go to be alone on the morning of Absalom's execution and meet each other along the way; again both respectful and gentle. Both men come together in a new generation through the young and innocent Jarvis.
Posted by debra g #85203 at Mar 20, 2009 8:07 PM || Report this post || Reply

Both men are reflections of each other in a sense. As Kumalo leaves Ndotsheni for the first time and ventures beyond his comfort zone and range of knowledge he is forced to come to terms with things which would have previously upset and/or offended him. Jarvis experiences the same type of growth during his time to Johannesburg and upon returning home has a new love and respect for the people of his valley. The differences would come along the lines that Kumalo, being a man of God, never sees in terms of race. Jarvis on the other hand is a wealthy white male looking down upon all Blacks in South Africa until his eyes are opened by the work of his late son.
Posted by max w #90793 at Apr 27, 2009 6:31 PM || Report this post || Reply

 

You must login to post to this topic.

Existing Users

New Users

Must contain six characters and at least one digit.

Related Content for Cry, the Beloved Country