|
Summary and Analysis of Lines 1-139
Beginning of the play to the waking of the Eumenides (Lines 1-139) Summary: We are just outside the sanctuary of Pythian Apollo, in Delphi. The Pythia, Apollo's priestess, sings a prayer that honors the gods who have prophesied from this shrine. The first was Earth, then Themis, then Phoebe, and then fourth was Apollo. Apollo is the fourth in this tradition of divine seers; he is the spokesman of his father, Zeus, king of the gods. The position of prophet has always been passed from god to god peacefully, rather than through force. The Pythia prepares to begin her day as the spokeswoman of Apollo. She enters the temple and almost immediately comes out again, terrified because of what she has seen. A man is seated in the suppliant's seat, his hands dripping with blood, carrying a bloodied sword in one hand and an olive branch wrapped with wool in the other hand. Surrounding him are gorgon-like creatures, dark and revolting, eyes oozing foul liquids. These creatures sleep. The Pythia trusts in Apollo to clear things up. The temple doors open, revealing Orestes and the sleeping Furies. Apollo and Hermes are there as well. Apollo affirms that he will stand by Orestes' side; it is he who has put the Furies to sleep. He expresses disgust for the Furies, and instructs Orestes to go to the city of Athena. There, he must clasp the idol of Athena. They will find people to judge his case, and Orestes will be purged of his mother's curse. Apollo asks Hermes to escort Orestes, reminding Hermes that Orestes is his suppliant and the wanderer must be treated well in accord with the laws of Zeus. (Note: the Greeks ascribed much importance to the rights of the suppliant. A suppliant was a person in desperate need who put himself at the mercy of another; violation of the suppliant's right to protection and hospitality was a great wrong. The Curse on the House of Atreus began with the slaughter of Thyestes children, and part of the horror of the act was that Atreus violated Thyestes' rights as a suppliant.) Hermes, Orestes, and Apollo exit. Clytaemestra's ghost enters, bemoaning her fate. Among the dead, she is condemned. No god protects her, but she can still have her revenge if the Furies keep after Orestes. During her life, she gave the Furies offerings; she reminds them of this and asks if the offerings were in vain. She tries to rouse them from their sleep, telling them that Orestes is laughing at them, berating them for being less helpful allies than Apollo. After much prodding, the Furies cry out in their sleep; even in their dreams, they chase Orestes. Clytaemestra makes another attempt to rouse them, inciting them to drive on despite fatigue. She wants them to make Orestes suffer horribly. AnalysisThe Eumenides' important themes include the contrast or struggle between the old and the new, between savagery and civilization, between the primal and the rational. This theme is expressed in the progression of old to new gods. Although these forces come into conflict, the drive of the play is to reconcile these opposites. The Eumenides opens with a story of peaceful progression from the old to the new. The beautiful song of the Pythia recounts the history of the shrine, which once was in possession of ancient goddesses much older than Apollo. The primal goddesses handed down the position of seer peacefully: this peaceful handover provides a powerful contrast to the violent wars between Zeus and the older Titans. It suggests an alternative to the eradication of the ancient; Apollo is fourth in a proud tradition of peaceful succession. The Eumenides, or the Furies, are the Chorus of this play. They are ancient goddesses, residents of the Pit, and they are brutal and physically repulsive. The sight of them disgusts the Pythia. They also are repugnant to Apollo, who provides a great contrast to them. He is a younger god, one of the Olympians, and he is a male god of rationality. The Furies, in contrast, are brutal creatures of revenge. They are ancient. Apollo cannot destroy them, but here we see him overpower them. He has put them all to sleep, and the hapless ghost of Clytaemestra has to wake them and shame them into keeping up the hunt. Although everyone speaks of their viciousness and ugliness, Aeschylus takes the edge off the Furies in this opening scene: when we first see them, they are like sleeping babies or old women. They are vulnerable, exhausted, and there is something comical about the way they chase after Orestes in their dreams and talk in their sleep. Clytaemestra's ghost is embittered and fixated on one thing: revenge. There is something pitiable about her here: when she describes her ill treatment by the other spirits, she speaks of how they have forgotten all of her reasons for doing what she did. By having Clytaemestra speak of how others have forgotten her suffering, Aeschylus is briefly making us remember it. He is aware that Orestes will receive forgiveness for his act while Clytaemestra will go unforgiven. But although he allows us to feel sorry for Clytaemestra, her fate is part of his vision of justice. Justice should not be overly compassionate, or overly understanding. In Clytaemestra's death, order will be restored and the rightful heir will again sit on the throne. But a reader who tries to evaluate Aeschylus on his own terms will see that he has a beautiful vision of order and healing that is hopeful and full of faith. Although we feel sorry for Clytaemestra here, her obsession with punishing her son undermines sympathy. Feeling sorry for Clytaemestra does not necessarily mean hoping that she will get what she wants, which in this case is more bloodshed. And there is nothing rational about her claim that she goes dishonored among the dead because of the Furies' incompetence. Revenge will not restore Clytaemestra to the honored ranks of the dead, but she clings to the idea that it will. Apollo promises that once Orestes reaches Athena, all will be made right: "You will be rid of your afflictions, once and for all" (l. 83). The implication is that not only will Orestes be cleansed of his mother's curse, but that the Curse on the House of Atreus will finally come to an end. The Olympian gods are intervening in human events, putting an end to a cycle of violence that has gone on too long. Cleansing or purification is one of the themes of this play, and it is made possible by concerted effort between gods and men and reconciliation of the old with the new. Finally, the violence will stop.
Summary and Analysis of Lines 140-234
From the waking of the Furies to the scene change from Delphi to Athens. (Lines 140-234) Summary: The Eumenides wake up, and begin to howl. They cry out that Apollo has robbed them of their rightful prey, a man who has committed the terrible sin of matricide. The Furies accuse Apollo of injustice and offending the old order, saying that by championing Orestes the Olympian god stains his own shrine. Apollo enters again, not bothering to hide his disgust for the Furies. He tells them to leave his temple. The Furies accuse Apollo of wrongdoing, reminding him that he was the one who commanded Orestes to kill Clytaemestra. Apollo is responsible, and he has had the nerve to offer sanctuary to the killer. He has prevented the Furies from doing their duty, which is to punish matricides. Apollo asks about Clytaemestra's wrongs: the woman killed her husband. The Eumenides respond that the murder was not committed against one who was related to her by blood. Orestes' sin is worse, because he killed his own kin. Apollo argues that the bond of marriage is sacred, and for the Furies to punish one murder and not the other makes void their claims of righteousness. Orestes' case will be put before Pallas Athene, and the great goddess will be the judge. The Furies insist that nothing will stop them from hounding Orestes. Apollo insists, with equal force, that he will protect Orestes. AnalysisWe see the clash between the old and the new deities. The Eumenides protest Apollo's interference, as he seeks to deny or beat back powers older than himself. The Furies insistence on Orestes' guilt has its own logic, as does Apollo's insistence on the guilt of Clytaemestra; their different arguments reflect their natures. The Furies emphasize the sacredness of kindred blood while Apollo emphasizes the sacredness of the marriage bond. The older, primal goddesses are defending the bond that is in the blood; it is the more basic and primitive link, between child and parent, that even animals recognize. The marriage bond is much newer than the bond of blood; marriage is the product of civilization and social constructions, and Apollo defends its sanctity eloquently. He symbolizes rationality and civilization, while the Furies are symbols of the primal and primitive. Apollo characterizes them as evil, but it is only because his nature is difficult to reconcile to theirs. His disgust for them is understandable, but it is also unhelpful. The Furies are brutal, but they are part of nature, and their arguments have their own logic. He can overpower them, but he cannot destroy them; Apollo's limitation parallels the ways that civilization and rationality cannot eradicate primal instincts. Later in the play, Athene will be able to reconcile the primal power symbolized by the Furies with the rationality and civilization represented by the Olympians. The debate about Orestes shows the difficulty of assessing a man's guilt or innocence. The history of the House of Atreus is an example of how murder and violence escalate out of control. Without recourse to courts, vengeance is the way to try to get justice. This play will end with the establishment of a court to judge homicides; civilization and rationality will provide a way to control violence and dispense justice. Gods and men work together to create an institution in which murder cases can be weighed and judged.
Summary and Analysis of Lines 235-565
From the scene change to the re-entrance of Athene with twelve jurors and a herald. (Lines 235-565) Summary: The scene changes from the temple of Apollo at Delphi to the Acropolis in Athens, before Athene's temple and statue. Orestes takes the suppliant position at the feet of Athene's statue, asking her to help him. The Furies enter, hot on his trail. They find him seeking protection from Athene, and they tell him that only his blood can answer for the blood of his mother. The Furies torment him with promises of the suffering he will endure at their hands. The exhausted and terrified Orestes defends himself, not denying the charge of matricide, but defending his character and saying that Apollo has cleansed him of his guilt. He now calls on Athene to protect him, showing faith that she can hear him no matter where she may be. The Chorus gives a long response. They tell Orestes that he is theirs to devour, and the Olympians cannot protect him. The Eumenides are agents of the most basic and ancient form of justice. The blood that Orestes spilled can only be paid for by the spilling of his own blood. The torment of guilty mortals has been the Furies' office from the first moments of the world. They seek to bypass the authority of Zeus, who has declared them outcasts. The guilty receive their punishment; the Furies are strong and cannot be appeased with words. Athene enters and asks the identity of Orestes and the Eumenides. Athene listens to the grievances of the Furies, but suspects that they tell only half the truth about Orestes. She will ask him herself; the Furies trust her to adjudicate the case. Orestes insists that he is no supplicant, and that he has been absolved of the blood on his hands. Orestes tells her his story; the goddess Athene acknowledges his rights, but also acknowledges the position of the Furies. The matter is too difficult even for her to judge. She goes to select a group of men to sit in council and judge Orestes' case; it will be the foundation for a jury that will judge all future murder cases. The Chorus sings again, claiming that if Orestes goes free the values and laws of the new gods will be proven false. Fear and violence are a part of justice, and the Furies make sure that the guilty do not go unpunished. AnalysisThe Eumenides are one of the most interesting Choruses in all of the Greek tragedies. Usually, Choruses are made of benign onlookers: the citizens of the city, or the servants of the household. The Chorus provides exposition and rushes of beautiful poetry. Here, the Chorus is composed of Orestes' antagonists. Instead of beautiful odes praising nature, the Furies deliver terrifying and intense songs of death and destruction. They are not exactly evil, but they are dark and brutal. Aeschylus use of the Chorus in this play shows the incredible range of his poetic imagination. The Eumenides is overall an extraordinarily optimistic work, presenting a powerful and hopeful vision of the relationships between man and god, past and present. The play provides a happy and harmonious ending to the Oresteia. But from the mouths of the Furies, Aeschylus is able to deliver many dark and intense images. The tone of the play is balanced between optimism and terror, with fear dominating the play's first half and optimism and rationality dominating the second half. The beginning of the trial marks this shift in tone. Another interesting aspect of the Furies is that they repeat entire long passages verbatim. The effects are numerous. For one, the repetition is hypnotic and eerie. Their song to Orestes is a song of the hunt, and the repetitions amplify the intensity of the Furies' emotions. It also fits in nicely with the Furies' age and primal nature. There is something primitive and ritualized about them; when they repeat whole passages verbatim, they seem even less human, more removed, more mythical. They become mysterious speakers of intense, ferocious, and mysterious incantations. After the reading of the verdict later in the play, the repetitions are used to achieve a somewhat different effect. The Furies are absolutely essential to the action; it is impossible to tell the same story without them. In many plays by Sophocles and, to an even greater extent, Euripides, the Chorus is not an absolutely essential part of the action. For these later playwrights, it often seems possible to rewrite the play without the Chorus while keeping the fundamental elements of the plot intact. That is not the case for The Eumenides. Note the difference between the ways that Apollo and Athene treat the Furies. Apollo has nothing but disgust for them. Athene treats them respectfully, but she also insists on being fair to Orestes. The central theme of this play is the struggle/conflict between opposites, and the reconciliation of those opposites. Athene herself is a symbol for that kind of reconciliation. She is female, but she is also a warrior: Aeschylus has her enter dressed in full body armor. She is as rational as her half-brother Apollo, but she is also compassionate and does not react with disgust at the sight of the Furies. She is woman, but she is born of her father: according to myth, she sprang from her father's skull. She is the goddess of wisdom and crafts as well as warfare, making both the creative and the destructive within her jurisdiction. She reconciles the best attributes the Greeks traditionally ascribed to the masculine and the feminine. Note that the Furies listen to her and speak to her with tremendous respect. They trust her to stand as fair judge over Orestes' case. The theme of purification comes up again and again, with the Furies insisting that Orestes is still stained by his mother's blood, while Orestes claims that Apollo has already purified him. Orestes insistence on his innocence goes so far as to make him claim proudly that he is no supplicant (even as clasps Athene's idol in the suppliant position). As a man free of guilt, he has come simply to rid himself of the Furies. But Athene seems to think that Orestes is indeed a supplicant, because she quietly labels him as such a few moments after he claims that he is not one. Though Orestes claims repeatedly that he has been purified, citing the rituals of cleansing and the sacrifices he has made at Apollo's shrine, the rituals seem to have been insufficient. For one thing, his sacrifices were made to Apollo, and Apollo is not the god he needs to appease. At the beginning of the play, Aeschylus suggests symbolically that Orestes still bears the stain of guilt: when the Pythia sees Orestes, his hands are stained with blood. The blood on the hands is a repeated image of The Eumenides. It is the Furies' favorite phrase for describing Orestes guilt, and Orestes' hands literally stained with blood in the play's opening suggests that he has not yet been purified. His continuing impurity suggests the need for a new step in humanity's development. Ancient rituals and sacrifice of animals are not adequate to deal with Orestes' actions. It will take the rational methods of a court to settle this matter once and for all. Through the deliberations of a court of justice, Orestes will be purified. Reason and civilized institution will wash away the bloodstains on the House of Atreus, ending the supernatural power of the Curse. Justice will come about through the courts, but the Furies represent an important face of justice. When Athene leaves to gather the jurors, the Furies sing of the vital role that they play in the world. Fear, they argue, is part of justice. To deny the Furies' rights is to invite anarchy. The relationship between justice and fear is another important theme of The Eumenides. Part of Aeschylus' vision is that fear, violence, and punishment are necessary tools of justice. Athene's incorporation of the Furies into Athens' pantheon shows recognition of this fact. The negative side of fear and violence is that when these forces are the only tools of justice, unalleviated by reason and compassion, violence gets out of control. The self-perpetuating Curse on the House of Atreus is the prime example of this phenomenon.
Summary and Analysis of Lines 566-753
From the re-entrance of Athene with jurors and herald to the reading of the verdict. (Lines 566-753) Summary: Athene re-enters, with the jury of twelve citizens and a herald. She instructs the herald to blow his trumpet, so that all of the citizens of Athens will watch the proceedings, which will form the basis of the court for all time. Apollo enters, to testify on Orestes' behalf. Athene presides over the trial. The Furies question Orestes about his mother's murder. When they accuse him of being guiltier than Clytaemestra because he killed someone of the same blood as himself, Orestes asks Apollo to guide his response. Apollo argues with the Furies, implying that Zeus authorized Clytaemestra's death and describing in detail the way that Agamemnon was murdered. The Furies say that the Olympians are hypocritical for prioritizing the death of the father, for Zeus himself put his own father in shackles. Apollo cannot veil his disgust for the Furies as he argues that there is a great difference between shackling a man and murdering him. Apollo also argues for paternal rights, saying that the father, as the one who plants the seed, is the only true parent. A person can have a father and no mother, and as proof of this idea Apollo points to Athene, who was born from her father's skull instead of the womb of her mother. Therefore, Orestes' murder of his mother must be seen in light of the killing of Orestes' father. Athene asks if the arguments have all been made. When the two parties agree that all has been said, Athene takes a moment to establish this site as the site for the court in all time to come. She advises the citizens of Athens to shy from anarchy and from tyranny alike; she warns them of the danger of corruption and the sanctity of law. She also tells them that fear must be a part of justice. The court will be like a sentry for the city of Athens, protecting her citizens from injustice and violence. The jurors begin to deliberate over the verdict, and the Chorus and Apollo both swagger and speak of their strength, and the consequent dangers of upsetting them. Athene seems unshaken by the threats; she casts her ballot in favor of Orestes, being without a mother herself. She admits that she is always sides with the male. Her vote will decide Orestes' fate if the jurors are tied. There is a moment of suspense, as Orestes frets about what the verdict will be and the ballots are counted. Athene announces that the ballots are tied: Orestes is free. AnalysisRemember that Aeschylus was an Athenian; his city was particularly devoted to the goddess Athene, and she is depicted here as majestic and wise. She uses the problem of Orestes as an opportunity to establish a new institution for justice, for the protection of her city and its people. Athens was a democracy, although one with a very limited electorate. A relatively small number of free male citizens ran the government; women did not vote, nor did slaves. Limitations of their democracy aside, Athenians considered themselves more free and wise than their neighbors. They had a strong distrust of dictatorship, although they were known to have dictators during times of instability. Athenians believed that rationality and deliberation were the most useful tools for making a decision, and that decisions are often best made in council. Not even Athene considers herself up to the task of deciding Orestes' fate. She brings in twelve jurors, hoping that a group of people together will be wiser than one judge alone. Her choice reveals the democratic sentiments of Aeschylus and his city. Athene has the citizens of Athens attend the trial, so that they can see for themselves the methods for dispensing justice. Here, the stage parallels life: just as the citizens of Athens onstage watch the trial, the real-life citizens of Athens are sitting in the audience watching the artistic representation of the trial. The section foreshadows the shift in scope we will see in just a few short moments. Orestes is becoming less central to the action; he barely speaks at his own trial, and instead has Apollo answer for him. The clash at the trial is not between Orestes and the Furies, but between Apollo and the Furies. The meaning is clear. Apollo and the Furies, and all the forces they represent, are battling; Orestes' character is hardly significant. Drama here is not drama of character, but drama of forces: history, progress, and myth. Orestes steps back and asks Apollo to speak for him. Apollo is a symbol for the male, the rational, the young, and the civilized. The Furies represent the female, the violent, the old, and the primal. These two forces clash over Orestes' fate, and the Furies themselves say that more is at stake than one man. The trial will set a precedent for how justice is to be dispensed for all time to come. The arguments made at court reveal the Athenian love for rhetoric and the art of debate. Although Apollo's argument for the supremacy of a father's rights is totally unscientific, he structures his argument like a good public speaker. He responds to the cross examination of the Furies with energy and confidence. Although Athene represents a reconciliation of the opposing forces represented by Apollo and the Furies, Aeschylus' vision is very patriarchal. Part of Athene's beauty, as we see it here, is that she always, by her own admission, sides with men. Male power and female power have struggled against each other throughout the trilogy; this clash of feminine and masculine strengths has been one of the constant themes of all three plays. Throughout, Aeschylus sets up male power as correct and right. Agamemnon and Orestes are the rightful rulers of Argos, whatever their sins; Clytaemestra, no matter what her justifications, upsets the right order of the world when she tries to sit on the throne. In The Eumenides, divine female power has many shape. The Furies represent an ancient, primal, feminine power. The Pythia recounts the history of Apollo's temple and the position of prophet, and, significantly, all of the deities who previously held Apollo's position were female. But they have handed power and the prophetic gift to Apollo. And the Furies, despite the respect that their age warrants, have been outcast by Zeus himself, the greatest and most powerful being, the ultimate father and god. In Athene, we see a reconciliation of male and female nature. She is a powerful female, but she is viewed as benevolent in part because she uses her power and wisdom to support male authority. She is her father's daughter, literally: she was born of his skull rather than from the womb of a woman. Aeschylus does not seek to seriously question this patriarchal order. He views it as correct, desirable. He makes place for feminine power and authority, but it must be secondary to and supportive of male-dominated order. We should not feel the need to apologize for Aeschylus' views on gender, nor should we accept it as adequate in light of modern perspectives on gender and equality. He was a man of his time, and the beauty of his vision is his faith that the existence of seemingly opposing forces is a source of strength and hope rather than despair. Athene calls on her people to remember that terror and justice go hand-in-hand. Fear has a role in preserving order. Her advice about fear and justice foreshadows the offer she will make to the Furies. The theme of integration and reconciliation works on many levels, and Aeschylus sees the combination of terror and reason as justice's strength rather than its downfall. Closely connected is the theme that man needs to come to terms with the savagery of the past, with the power and energy of the primal, rather than destroy or efface these forces. The Furies will not be destroyed at the end of the play, nor will they remain outcasts. They must be incorporated into the new order. Athene supports Orestes, and the jurors are tied. This close verdict shows that Aeschylus recognizes the complexity of Orestes' case; this complexity is exactly the reason why courts are necessary for the dispensation of justice. The complex circumstances surrounding Orestes' case require the wisdom of the many: the collective judgment of the jurors and Athene is far superior to the judgment of one or the blunt instrument of revenge.
Summary and Analysis of Lines 754-1047
Orestes' thanks and promise to the end of the play. (Lines 754-1047) Summary: Orestes thanks Athene, his speech overflowing with enthusiasm and earnestness. She has saved him, and he knows it. He promises that Argos will forever be the ally of Athens, and Orestes' spirit will forsake the future people of Argos should they ever turn against Athens. He exits, to return to his homeland as its new king. Apollo goes with him. The Furies are outraged by the verdict, saying that the new gods have trampled the old ways. They promise to punish the land for this decision. Athene reasons with them, pointing out that the ballot was close and that the decision was reached by a fair trial. She offers them a place under the earth in Athens, to receive offerings from the people. The Furies repeat their last speech verbatim, voicing their outrage and promising to bring destruction on the land. Athene, unshaken, continues to reason with them. She reminds them that she alone of the gods knows the location of the keys to Zeus' case of thunderbolts. She is powerful, and has Zeus behind her, but it need not come to that. Athens is a rich land, and the Furies can have offerings, too. The Furies do not believe Athene. They do not believe that the people of Athens will be able to treat them with kindness; they bemoan their fate as outcasts, their ancient rights denied. Athene continues to reason with them: she tells them that she understands their anger. She also acknowledges that they have a wisdom she lacks because of their great age. But Athene, too, possess a great wisdom, different from that of the Furies. She tells them that Athens will have a great future; if the Furies come to Athens as beneficiaries, as great goddesses who preserve peace and do good, protecting the country from the threat of civil war, then the Furies' days will be rich and beautiful. In response, the Chorus repeats, verbatim, their expressions of disbelief and anger about their status as outcasts. Athene patiently continues to tell them about the benefits of accepting her offer. Instead of continuing in the path of hatred and destruction, Athene offers them peace and position. The Furies ask about the details of Athene's offer, and Athene responds to every question: they will have a comfortable home, and they will power over the prosperity of men. The Furies can hardly believe the generosity of the offer. They ask Athene what kind of prayer they should say for the land. Athene describes, in beautiful language, a city prosperous and blessed. The Furies accept Athene's offer, taking a position by Athene's side, promising to defend the interests of Athens and praying for the prosperity of the city. Athene establishes the Furies' authority as the dispensers of prosperity or ruin. Athene and the Eumenides speak in turns, Athene establishing the Furies' authority and thanking Persuasion for helping her to tame them, while the Furies repeatedly bless the city. The tone of the Furies' speech changes to one of gentleness; their words are about peace, mercy, and love. Athene orders that the Furies be brought to their new home, under the earth of Athens. There they will preside over the fortunes of the city, and act as the city's guardians. A second Chorus forms, made up of the women who serve Athene. They close the play singing of the harmonious arrangement brought about by their goddess, and they bring the Furies to their new home. Peace will reign between the Athenians and their new goddesses; it has all come to pass according to the wills of Destiny and Zeus. AnalysisOrestes exits after line 777. For almost a quarter of the play, then, Orestes is completely absent. The trilogy named after him finishes without him. The Eumenides is quite different from the other two parts of the Oresteia. The layers of symbolism (viper, serpent, poison, the net) are no longer present. We have gods that symbolize greater forces, but it might be more accurate to say that the gods are embodiments of these forces; the gods for Aeschylus are simultaneously symbols of abstract forces and real personalities. Also, for readers whose exposure to Greek tragedy has been limited to Oedipus the King, Antigone, or Medea, the ending of this play may come as a surprise. Indeed, for readers whose only exposure to Greek tragedy has been the first and second part of the Oresteia, the ending may come as a surprise. The ending of the trilogy is more than merely happy: it is a beautiful, lyrical, and optimistic ending that points to a great future. A great and beautiful fate awaits Orestes and his kingdom, the friendship between Argos and Athens, the Eumenides, and the city of Athens itself. The scope of the trilogy has opened up. Orestes exits promptly after his verdict, leaving Athene and the Furies to hammer out the beginnings of a new future. The tendency of the Furies to repeat themselves is put to new use after the reading of the verdict. The Furies cannot initially see beyond their rage. In response to Athene's powerful arguments, they can only repeat threats and old grievances. These repetitions also suggest the directness of their minds; they are fully invested in certain thoughts and ideas. They have not the suppleness of thought possessed by Athene and Apollo. When Athene tries to reason with them after the verdict, it takes a while to get through to them; the Furies repeat their list of grievances and threats verbatim before Athene's arguments begin to make any impression on them. But Athene is gracious, acknowledging the wisdom possessed by the Furies. While Clytaemestra used persuasion and flattery as part of her scheme to murder Agamemnon, Athene acknowledges Persuasion as her ally in taming the Furies (ll. 970-2). The abuses of Persuasion and Fear are corrected. Persuasion becomes the voice of reason, reconciliation, and diplomacy, and Fear becomes the tool of justice. In successfully bringing the Furies into the new order, Athene ends the danger of the new gods trampling the old ways. Apollo, unable to contain his disdain for the Furies throughout, exits in a huff with Orestes. It is Athene who is wise enough to recognize that the Furies are the embodiments of a vital aspect of Truth. They were gods before Athene and Apollo were born, and they have their own kind of wisdom. According to Aeschylus' vision, their ferocity and strength can be part of maintaining order. Integration in the Oresteia is not the fusion between equals; the many opposing forces we have seen (male versus female, old versus new, primal versus rationally) are reconciled by the arrangement at the end of the play, but in most cases, one force is subordinated to the other. Female power supports and submits to male power; the old make way for the new; the primal forces accept their place in a rational pantheon. Still, no force is eradicated. The subordinate forces are necessary to the new order. The strength of the new order is dependent on integrating the primal past. The Furies are powerful allies for the young city of Athens; they are significantly transformed after accepting Athene's offer, but at their core they retain their ferocity and power to strike fear into men's hearts. Aeschylus ends with a celebration of his own homeland and a tribute to Destiny and the plans of Zeus. The trilogy ends with the promise of a mighty destiny for Athens; the city's strength will come from its incorporation of the archaic alongside the rational, the violent alongside the gentle. Reason will be among the city's tools, as will ferocity and strength of arms. Zeus and Destiny, sing the women of the Second Chorus, have willed that the Furies and Athene should make peace with one another. We have been made to understand the will of the gods. The urge to create teleology, or explain the ways of the divine in human terms, is an important theme of the trilogy. All of the events that have rocked the House of Atreus have led to this great triumph. The trilogy has explained to us how the people of the House of Atreus played a part in the progression of civilization. Brutality followed brutality for generations, until the gods intervened. Out of the need to deal with this violence rose the first homicide court of Athens. We must see the earlier tragedies of the house as part of a greater design, one leading to a hopeful and harmonious new order. Aeschylus captures a mythical moment in history, one in which the world was torn between a savage and archaic past and the bold new order of Greek civilization, the young Olympian gods, and rationality. The difficulty of the struggle between these two worlds is dramatized by the cycle of violence in the House of Atreus and the clash between Apollo and the Furies. The Oresteia is about the growing pains of a nascent civilization. In the end, the new has to integrate the old rather than destroy it; with help from the gods, the young is reconciled with the ancient. Out of the tragedies of the House of Atreus, Destiny has raised up a richer, deeper order, strengthening and civilizing men and gods alike.
ClassicNote on The Eumenides
|